In My View: What you’re expecting me to have standards?

So I spent my last post talking about the nature of “good” shows, but I haven’t really addressed Coburn’s fundamental conundrum.

What makes a show an all-time favorite? Or put better, what measures do I use to judge a show?

Now, I’ll admit this is a hard question to answer because when I watch a show, I’m reacting to the show. I’m not trying to dissect exactly what I like about the show. I don’t tend to categorize my complaints when I get around to dissecting the show. All of that makes this a tough question to answer.

Expectations, Standards and Biases

Recently, I watched Tokko. Now all-in-all, I enjoyed watching it, which got me thinking. What was it about the show I liked? That answer was pretty simple, I expected the main character to get superpowers about two episodes into the show. Instead, he spent half of the series without any kind of superpowers at all. Then after spending a long time developing the characters, building suspense and creating a level of excitement, he got superpowers.

In short, Tokko exceeded my expectations. For the sake of the argument, expectations are what I expect to see either after the preview or the first episode. My expectations are usually pretty low. If I’m watching a shounen fighting show, I expect to have a young plucky hero who will eventually have to fight a menacing bad guy after discovering his hidden reserves. If I get that, I’m happy.

So if a show does something I’m not expecting it to, then it can end one of two ways. Either I liked it, and the show exceeded my expectations, or I hated it, and the show fell below my expectations. Now my expectations aren’t set in stone, if a show exceeds my expectations, then I expect it to continue to exceed my expectations. (That said, I’ll usually forgive a show for having a few bad episodes.)

Now standards are what I want a show to do. I want a show to have a multi-layered, character-driven plot. I want shows to have flawed heroes. I want characters to be noticeably different at the end of the show then they were at the beginning of the show. To be honest, I don’t expect these things. If I expected them, then they would be, well, expectations.

Standards aren’t an all or nothing category. If a show meets one or two of my standards, I’m impressed.

On a side note, I’ve found a lot of long-term reviewers tend to start replacing their expectations with their standards. Honestly, I find it a bit sad because they’re always going to be disappointed.

On the other hand, biases are just stuff I like. For instance, I like fanatics. I find them fascinating. If a show has a fanatic then I’m probably going to like it. But I don’t expect a show to have a fanatic.

Now it is kind of tricky to separate biases and standards. Standards apply to any fiction. While biases are just things I like, such as fanatics or war epics or WWI-style dogfights or dark, brooding anti-heroes.

What makes an all-time favorite show for me

So how does all of this sort out? Pretty simply actually, but a lot depends on the show. In all of the cases, these shows exceeded my expectations. In most of the cases, they hit at least one or two of my standards and they all featured at least one (or in the case of Last Exile A LOT) of my biases.

Advertisements

3 Comments

  1. So, you’re PROBABLY going to like Mahoraba, Naruto, and Ranma?

  2. “On a side note, I’ve found a lot of long-term reviewers tend to start replacing their expectations with their standards. Honestly, I find it a bit sad because they’re always going to be disappointed.”

    I replaced my expectation with my standards, which is actually sad because I notice my expectations are lower and lower. No, actually while I do see this happening, I think I still unconsciously separate the two for the most part.

    I don’t know why you think expectations being replaced with standards will lead to disappointment. 😀

  3. @ Author – To be fair, yes and no. As far as Ranma goes, when I watched it (about 12 years ago) I didn’t have any problems with the show. That said, I have a bias against situational comedy in general. But if it’s what I’m in the mood for then I don’t have any problems. Now I haven’t watched Naruto (mostly because I don’t feel like investing the time and money into the show), but I did like Yu Yu Hakusho and I liked the cell saga of DBZ and I’m enjoying Toaru Majistu no Index (not sure if I got that right.)

    To be fair, I’m using like in a very general way (which is always a problem in semantic arguments.) Meaning, I enjoyed the show and I was entertained not that I had any kind of rabid fanboy devotion to the show.

    @ omo – Mostly because I think the standards generally are higher than our expectations. So when I read a review which says, “Oh it’s just the same old stuff.” I start wondering if the reviewer ever watches anything they actually like.

    But then again, my expectations are usually pretty low myself.


Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s